Paid Members mim731 Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 17 minutes ago, SuperBacon said: I agree with Devon that this is a bollocks award as I don't think subjective individual awards should be given for team sports, but even putting my Spurs allegiance aside (as to be honest once a player leaves I really don't give a shit) it's impossible to say that over the last year he hasn't earned it. He's a ridiculous player who's had a banner year in his career, and the others on the list haven't come near his level. Yeah this is bang on for me. I don't like Kane for many reasons, but I can't see a wild issue with him winning a bollocks award after having a really good year. Especially as no-one else seems to have put forward a particularly convincing argument for someone being a better individual player in that time period for one reason or another. Quote
Tennessee Moltisanti Posted October 27 Posted October 27 2 hours ago, mim731 said: Yeah this is bang on for me. I don't like Kane for many reasons, but I can't see a wild issue with him winning a bollocks award after having a really good year. Especially as no-one else seems to have put forward a particularly convincing argument for someone being a better individual player in that time period for one reason or another. He had a good year, but he's not the best footballer in the world, which is what it should be awarded on. If it was true to it's original point of being awarded to the best footballer, Messi would have 20. But it isn't. Quote
Paid Members mim731 Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 Just now, Tennessee Moltisanti said: He had a good year, but he's not the best footballer in the world, which is what it should be awarded on. If it was true to it's original point of being awarded to the best footballer, Messi would have 20. But it isn't. The top football journalists of the world who form the judging panel clearly don't agree. It's a subjective award. Why you're putting this much stock onto arguing about it I have no idea Quote
Ironic Indie Lad Posted October 27 Posted October 27 I’m still arguing Beckham should have won it ‘99 Quote
Paid Members Devon Malcolm Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 9 minutes ago, Ironic Indie Lad said: I’m still arguing Beckham should have won it ‘99 The first person to argue for anyone other than a forward, good lad. Quote
Paid Members Cod Eye Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 For me, it's become and award for the player who has had the best 12 months on the pitch. Be that goals, assists, influence, trophies or a mix of the above, whoever has performed their role the best deserves the award. I like that, and I think its how it should be! I dont think, if you use that rationale, that Kane is an unworthy winner. Did i read somewhere its the second most goals ever scored over a calendar year? And if you use the "he plays for Bayern, he SHOULD win everything and score tons), why has all the word class forwards they have had like Levondowski(for example) not score 70 plus goals in a season? I honestly think we've been lucky enough to watch one of the best 2 English goal scorers of all time(with Jimmy Greaves), and I think the fact he had to actually work to become that(those who coached him have said he was never a natural finisher when coming through) makes him a shining example to ALL young players in an age where they seem to think they are owed a career. Well done Harry Kane! On the other hand, however they made a Ballon D'or shortlist without a single Barnsley player on there after the 12 months they have had, Is a travesty! You going down to League 2 for the first time in my life Reds! Quote
Paid Members gmoney Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 Frank Leboeuf never won = fake award Quote
Awards Moderator Frankie Crisp Posted October 27 Awards Moderator Posted October 27 Platini winning it instead of Neville Southall in 1985 was another dagger to the heart of this being taken seriously. Quote
Paid Members Jazzy G Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 4 hours ago, Statto said: But do you like Rachel Stevens? If is was in your shoes... Quote
Mr_Danger Posted October 27 Posted October 27 It’s a load of bollocks. If Yamal was so deserving he wouldn’t need the Barcelona press machine and all his team mates campaigning for him to win it. Just like the Oscars the merit of the award loses something when it’s as much to do with PR and buzz as it is quality. Quote
TAFKA Jonny Vegas Posted October 27 Posted October 27 (edited) The award is nonsense but I don't agree at all that Kane should have won it. He's a great player and he had a great season but I don't think there's a reasonable argument that he had the best season of any player in football. I think the point about the environment within which he made his key achievements - domestic success and number of goals scored - is absolutely relevant. Bayern are miles ahead of anyone in Germany. That has to be taken into account. The biggest and two most pressured games of Kane's season in my opinion were the World Cup QF and SF. He was anonymous in both. Him being the "Best Player In The World" is ridiculous. Edited October 27 by TAFKA Jonny Vegas Quote
Fog Dude Posted October 27 Posted October 27 On 10/25/2026 at 5:56 PM, Gooner said: We probably will change the whole team for the game away on Tuesday at Fleetwood Town, go get a positive result and then I'm really looking forward to rocking up to Anfield next Sunday and putting the final nail in any hope they have of taking our title away from us this season. Sounds like you were looking forward to Arsenal getting to play at Highbury for the first time in over two decades. Pity they didn't turn up. Quote
Members SuperBacon Posted October 27 Author Members Posted October 27 To lose back to back penalty shoot outs to PSG and Fleetwood Town is some achievement. I did say that the League Cup needs scrapping. Can I shock you? Quote
Paid Members mim731 Posted October 27 Paid Members Posted October 27 Yeah that's sub optimal. Fair play to Fleetwood though. On the plus side it'll ease some potential fixture congestion. Silver linings. Quote
Mr_Danger Posted October 28 Posted October 28 The biggest surprise to me was that Kepa is now so shit that even Illan Meslier, a truly awful goalkeeper, is considered better than him. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.