Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Paid Members
Posted

A simple question here - which wrestlers do you think are or were better as babyfaces than heels? Doesn't mean they were bad heels as such, maybe they were underwhelming or just fit the role of babyface that bit better. Heck, maybe they were actually good as heels, but were even better good guys. 

That's not the case for my example, and the inspiration for this thread...

images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSO98FlDgq6PbV6NxgCiMe

Absolutely pisses charisma as a babyface, he has real 'top guy' vibes to him and comes across as cool, and likeable. For whatever reason, as a heel he loses almost all of that and ends up cutting meandering promos that don't quite hit the mark. He becomes...pretty boring. If you had only seen White as a heel, you'd be excused for thinking there was no way he could play the kind of babyface that he does. So yeah, Jay White is my pick for this - who is yours?

Posted
7 minutes ago, SuperBacon said:

Big Boss Man. I never liked him as a heel, I wanted to see him handcuff the shits of the WWF and dish out that sweet, sweet hard time.

See I loved him as a heel. Thought he was just so mean and dominant.  Never been a fan of them turning monsters to faces. The Natural Disasters being another one. 
 

In terms of who is or was better as a babyface - for me it would have to be Roddy Piper. I know he was an amazing heel back in the day, but to me he screams just mental babyface. 

  • Paid Members
Posted
8 minutes ago, SuperBacon said:

Big Boss Man. I never liked him as a heel, I wanted to see him handcuff the shits of the WWF and dish out that sweet, sweet hard time.

He was a cracking heel though. I don't think I could say he was better either way. He was a brilliant foe for Hogan, perfect opponent for the Mega Powers and then turned at the right time and was super-popular. He was definitely a better heel on his second run. Can't imagine cheering him for a second.

I think I'd throw Ric Flair in. He was a great heel for a time but for the whole time WCW was known as WCW, he was a brilliant babyface who kept wanting to turn heel because he's got the same instincts for wrestling as he has for marriages. The big plonker.  

  • Paid Members
Posted
2 hours ago, boshealecta said:

In terms of who is or was better as a babyface - for me it would have to be Roddy Piper. I know he was an amazing heel back in the day, but to me he screams just mental babyface. 

Absolutely. He had a vibe about him that was just immensely likeable, to the point that I was really torn for the match with Bret at WM8, adding to why it's one of my favourites ever. Even though I'd never met him, he just had this aura like that of an old family friend that we might actually know.

Bret was obviously better as a face. To the degree that they knew they couldn't make him an out-and-out heel even when they did turn him.

There are all the obvious ones - Sting, Ricky Steamboat, Cena, but one that's worthy of debate is Eddy Guerrero - he was a phenomenal heel, but when you get so over that the crowd point-blank refuse to let you turn heel, that's got to be a marker of a supreme babyface.

I'd also like to say that I much preferred Jarrett as a face, and I thought it was a massive shame they felt they had to make him a member of the Temu nWo in TNA - it was a horrendously wasted opportunity not to have the founder leading the charge against them.

  • Paid Members
Posted

Even when Eddy was a hell you had to cheer him because he was just so cheeky and likeable. I know he managed to get some great heel heat by feuding with Rey, but he was always just so darned good. You couldn't help but be entertained by him. 

Steve Austin wasn't a great heel in the WWF/E, but was beforehand in WCW, but when they actually turned him face it worked for him. I think the heel turn during the invasion didn't really work, but I also don't think he ever reached the same heights when he turned face against afterwards. Whether it was a lightning in a bottle thing or just that everything else had moved along I couldn't say. 

Obviously Goldberg. His heel turn and New Blood run in WCW was awful. 

  • Paid Members
Posted

I think Austin's character was just stale as fuck when he turned face again after the invasion angle was done.  To be fair to Austin, WWF in 02 was  pretty shite and he wasn't given much to work with. Feuding with Hall for Mania, biker Taker for a bit and then GM Flair (who somehow looked older in 02 than he did when he retired) after was never going to set the world on fire. Just a pity we never got that Eddie feud before Austin legged it. 

Posted

Obvious one for AEW would be Hangman, the heel run when he was feuding with Swerve was good but you only have to hear the pop for the opening gallop of his theme to know that guy was born to be a man of the people Babyface 

Similarly and surprisingly, Will Ospreay has been excellent as a gutsy face rather than a cocky heel these past few years

 

  • Paid Members
Posted
12 hours ago, RIDDUM_N_STYLE said:

Obvious one for AEW would be Hangman, the heel run when he was feuding with Swerve was good but you only have to hear the pop for the opening gallop of his theme to know that guy was born to be a man of the people Babyface 

 

I dunno, I thought Hangman was surprisingly brilliant as a heel and there's still a story to tell with him in that role. I get why you mention him, but this image alone has me disagreeing with you...

images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSbueCp2GQxiwCi1WHIGPu

Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, RedTwoster said:

I dunno, I thought Hangman was surprisingly brilliant as a heel and there's still a story to tell with him in that role. I get why you mention him, but this image alone has me disagreeing with you...

images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSbueCp2GQxiwCi1WHIGPu

I think what made his dark side Hangman run so good was it wasn't like he went heel and stayed that way for ages, he was heel because he was a babyface rightly going through a bit of crisis bordering on a full on breakdown. His absolute conviction that every action he did was completely justified due to Swerve and how the fans just accepted this psychopath was actually alright. It's very Bret '97. It's a babyface being a conflicted tweener in his own head because how dare you actually embrace the man who broke into my house. One of the best character beats ever.

Edited by Chili
Posted
12 hours ago, RIDDUM_N_STYLE said:

Obvious one for AEW would be Hangman, the heel run when he was feuding with Swerve was good but you only have to hear the pop for the opening gallop of his theme to know that guy was born to be a man of the people Babyface 

 

But that's also what made him so fucking good as a heel. The decent into madness. The screaming. The rage. Being completely out of control.

Sometimes the goodest of good guys makes the best heels.

  • Paid Members
Posted

Also, the complete hypocrisy. One of my favourite bits of his heel turn was very early on, when he came out with an injury, telling the fans that he loved their support and they knew he'd never lie to them, and he was gutted to have to pull out of the match - then at the end of the episode, revealing that he was actually lying, and screaming 'I had to lie! He made me! I had to lie!'. Just hilarious stuff.

Posted (edited)
5 minutes ago, DavidB6937 said:

But that's also what made him so fucking good as a heel. The decent into madness. The screaming. The rage. Being completely out of control.

Sometimes the goodest of good guys makes the best heels.

When actually IS his heel run too? Because I'd say it begins actually after he smashes Swerve's head in at All Out. After that he has some stuff with Jarrett, Jay White and then has than angle with Christopher Daniels where retiring him clears the fog in his head a bit before the beginning of the redemption arc. It's not even a run, it's a character flaw more than anything. Stupid man for his choice of mates, a genius at pulling everything though with his character on TV. When his career is done, I'd love one long comp of it to see all the ebbs and flows.

But I agree he actually is better as a babyface because of the euphoric hit of his triumphs.

Edited by Chili
  • Paid Members
Posted
Just now, Chili said:

I think what made his heel run so good was it wasn't like he went heel and stayed that way for ages, he was heel because he was a babyface rightly going through a bit of crisis bordering on a full on breakdown. His absolute conviction that every action he did was completely justified due to Swerve and how the fans just accepted this psychopath was actually alright. It's very Bret '97. It's a babyface being a conflicted tweener in his own head because how dare you actually embrace the man who broke into my house. One of the best character beats ever.

I thought the whole heel Hangman dynamic was brilliantly done.

I'm not usually that arsed about dualling chants, but one example I really loved was during All In 2024 when Hangman put his hands on Karen Jarrett. Half of our section was chanting Coward Shit at the scumbag and the other half were chanting back Cowboy Shit. It genuinely felt like the crowd were involved in a battle for Hangmans soul.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...