Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Paid Members
Posted

I think the only way they can conclude this year of mogging WWE with their ex-talent is doing the Shane McMahon vs. Darby Allin dream match at World’s End. 

Posted

Not watched it all yet, but just to say, Anarchy in the Arena is my favourite type of AEW match. The amount of times I've gone back to the 2025 one, and I imagine I will do the same with this one. I just think it's such a joy to watch, it even made me enjoy Gabe Kidd.

The 2 needle drops for when they first played Party Up with Daniel Garcia dancing and fighting, and then the second one when Gabe Kidd did the fake heel turn were perfect. A song I never expected to hear in AEW, but it made perfect sense. Moxley and Orange Cassidy going wild with forks together, Kemalito (my daughters love Kemalito) it's all just mad fun.

And I have to mention the 2 cinematic moments of The Conglomeration and Death Riders meeting in the middle of a desert to exchange a backpack, and Hangman and Brodido having a barroom brawl in some wild west town, exactly what I want from wrestling.

  • Paid Members
Posted

I think something AEW have learned from the likes of Miro and Malakai Black is that there's two kinds of "ex-WWE" - there's wrestlers who get released and see every other thing they do through the lens of "how will this help me get back to WWE?", and there's the wrestlers who choose to leave because they have something to prove. Ciampa, Dragunov, and now the Kasper Brothers are all people who chose not to renew their contracts. The New Level told them to piss off rather than accept a massive paycut, and were just a no-brainer to bring in, but they too have still shown at every opportunity that they've got something to prove and aren't just happy slumming it and going through the motions. Weirdly, the most "AEW was their second choice" vibes of any recent ex-WWE signings have been from the Motor City Machine Guns.

It helps that I barely saw anything of him in WWE, but I already don't think of Ilja Dragunov as an ex-WWE guy. Ciampa and Andrade, barely. When you get to someone like Swerve, the idea that he was ever a lower card WWE guy just seems bonkers now. 

One of the Kasper Brothers looked straight in the camera and shouted about how they chose to come to AEW because it's the best place in the world for tag team wrestling, and you have to think that if you're set on being a tag team, why would you ever sign with WWE when AEW's an option? They have about three tag teams to speak of, and despite having two sets of men's tag titles on the main roster, there has been one tag title match on a "PLE" this year. 

  • Paid Members
Posted
2 minutes ago, BomberPat said:

Weirdly, the most "AEW was their second choice" vibes of any recent ex-WWE signings have been from the Motor City Machine Guns.

I find it bizarre that they chose to sign with WWE ahead of AEW in the first place, but it's done them a heck of a lot of damage. As good as their matches with FTR were, I'm really struggling to take them seriously or buy them as any sort of threat. They need to at least establish who they are. Having a great match with FTR, a team that has, as best as I can remember, never had a bad match in AEW - doesn't make you stand out. They're deeply uninteresting. I've always considered Alex Shelley incredibly underrated, so I do think they have it in them to show something more, but they probably need to turn heel or something before they can do that. 

 

Posted
2 minutes ago, RedTwoster said:

I find it bizarre that they chose to sign with WWE ahead of AEW in the first place, but it's done them a heck of a lot of damage. As good as their matches with FTR were, I'm really struggling to take them seriously or buy them as any sort of threat. They need to at least establish who they are. Having a great match with FTR, a team that has, as best as I can remember, never had a bad match in AEW - doesn't make you stand out. They're deeply uninteresting. I've always considered Alex Shelley incredibly underrated, so I do think they have it in them to show something more, but they probably need to turn heel or something before they can do that. 

 

I'm lucky to watch them without the WWE stench because I didn't see any of it, though I don't think I've actually seen the Guns except that 2022 AEW cameo since like 2010 TNA when they had a thing with Beer Money.

  • Paid Members
Posted
8 minutes ago, RedTwoster said:

I find it bizarre that they chose to sign with WWE ahead of AEW in the first place, but it's done them a heck of a lot of damage. As good as their matches with FTR were, I'm really struggling to take them seriously or buy them as any sort of threat. They need to at least establish who they are. Having a great match with FTR, a team that has, as best as I can remember, never had a bad match in AEW - doesn't make you stand out. They're deeply uninteresting. I've always considered Alex Shelley incredibly underrated, so I do think they have it in them to show something more, but they probably need to turn heel or something before they can do that. 

My best guess is that WWE presented the best option for Alex Shelley post-wrestling; he's a physical therapist, and would have been an incredible asset to the Performance Center between that, his career and experience, and how good he is at guiding young wrestlers.

I agree about them in AEW - I'm a huge fan of theirs, Shelley especially, and I've loved the FTR matches, but they have to find something beyond "they're a really good tag team", or relying on their reputation from years ago. I don't think it helped that they've had no momentum prior to the FTR series - they debuted, then vanished off TV for months (I think this was while they were working on their band's album), then they showed up at All In for a segment with Cage & Cope, the Young Bucks, and FTR, only for the other three teams in that match to set up a TLC match with each other, without the Machine Guns even being part of the conversation. They need an opportunity to show more of their personality, but even beyond that, their presentation has made them look a bit second-rate so far.

Posted

I think it'd be cool if Brody and Bandido didn't turn heel, but still turned their back on Hangman. Internally the logic would be, "he got us sucked into hell and it's not entirely his fault, but it's still safer to part ways" - but they don't verbally express it. They just tell him they're gonna focus on the normal tag division or explore singles goals and then keep walking away when he approaches them. Hangman is hurt by this and retreats back into his best version - Anxious Millennial Cowboy who needs to rebuild his confidence - in a bit of a wrestling Banshees of Inisherin. Hangman can either get angry and go after Swerve for it or, as I'd prefer, take the long way around and spend a while struggling with internal anguish before eventually building himself back up. I'd actually shove him in the C2 now and have him wildly underperform. UK in Eurovision scores. Then start looking for opportunities to build him back. Maybe he looks for new friends/stables in the way the Dark Order helped him before, maybe they do/don't work out, but eventually finds his sense of self-worth etc.

8 hours ago, RedTwoster said:

Which title run was this? His first, I assume? His title run in 2026 was arguably the best run anyone has ever had with the World title, he was tremendous. Darby's 2026 run rivals it, though - he certainly had the best babyface run with the belt to date. 

The first one, yeah. But even then it wasn't like I thought, "MJF sucks, I'm outta here!" I loved the Adam Cole stuff, which was the last full feud I saw him in and I would still have said I'm an MJF fan. But I'm also aware that, somewhere in the back of my mind, there's a voice saying, "have I seen it all before with him? Is it going to be the exact same schtick? And if I was really into him as champ, would I have stopped watching wrestling entirely for the first time in 30 years on his watch?" I dunno. But, who knows, maybe I'll love it! I was praising Darby the other week for still feeling amazingly fresh despite being exactly the same as when I left. Maybe I'll feel the same about MJF.

  • Paid Members
Posted (edited)
44 minutes ago, textonly said:

The first one, yeah. But even then it wasn't like I thought, "MJF sucks, I'm outta here!" I loved the Adam Cole stuff, which was the last full feud I saw him in and I would still have said I'm an MJF fan. But I'm also aware that, somewhere in the back of my mind, there's a voice saying, "have I seen it all before with him? Is it going to be the exact same schtick? And if I was really into him as champ, would I have stopped watching wrestling entirely for the first time in 30 years on his watch?" I dunno. But, who knows, maybe I'll love it! I was praising Darby the other week for still feeling amazingly fresh despite being exactly the same as when I left. Maybe I'll feel the same about MJF.

I was saying all of that about MJF before his most recent title reigns, I think the entire forum was. Then his title reigns weren’t just better than expected, they were objectively brilliant. I’m hoping he can keep up the good form going forward.

Edited by RedTwoster
  • Paid Members
Posted

Just got finished with the show and very much enjoyed it - most everything I want to say has already been said I think, but...

- As ever with these shows, I think I benefitted from watching it across 3 sittings (3hrs last night, an hour at lunch and an hour just now). Allowed me to separate out the multi-man Texas Death and Anarchy in the Arena. I also skipped the Blood and Guts show as I was busy that week and really don't like War Games, so it didn't feel too overkill.

- OMG the set. My favourite thing about the show, honestly. Best AEW presentation ever, I think. Except maybe this year's Wembley.

- Kinda surprised they switched the Trios belts as Good/Bad/Guapo have a longer shelf life as a Trios act right now IMO - if nothing else they still need to rapidly murder Garrison/SoloRoto to close that little loop (which I very much like as a little bit of undercard silliness) - but I trust there's a wider story in there.

- Cruel I know but LOL at MJF booting a woman in the face jumping the rail and Schiavone immediately calling his involvement "a massive black eye"

- I like Andrade in many ways, but I've never really agreed with Schiavone's insistence he's incredibly cool. He certainly doesn't look cool carrying around a clipboard that he's had framed and lit for some reason.

Posted (edited)

Funniest thing about MJF's return, was him wearing the worst disguise ever. 

Why even fucking bother? 

Also I don't into buy his "I'm the real champion" story at all. Imo, that only really works when the previous champion (HBK with the IC title, for example) never lost the title.

Edited by The King Of Swing
Posted
36 minutes ago, The King Of Swing said:

Funniest thing about MJF's return, was him wearing the worst disguise ever. 

Why even fucking bother? 

Also I don't into buy his "I'm the real champion" story at all. Imo, that only really works when the previous champion (HBK with the IC title, for example) never lost the title.

I've only seen the clip on Facebook but from the admittedly small amount I know about MJF isn't it a dig at WWE  and their never ending masked men who don't need to be masked?

  • Awards Moderator
Posted
9 hours ago, The King Of Swing said:

Funniest thing about MJF's return, was him wearing the worst disguise ever. 

Why even fucking bother? 

Also I don't into buy his "I'm the real champion" story at all. Imo, that only really works when the previous champion (HBK with the IC title, for example) never lost the title.

I think his logic is that he only lost the title to Omega because Ospreay interfered on Kenny’s behalf. In MJF’s head, the match should have ended in a DQ due to cheating and he never really lost. Your classic hypocritical cheater.

  • Paid Members
Posted

finished the show last night. Loved Moné vs. Marina, and I thought Anarchy In The Arena was an insanely good time, with the exact opposite approach to what I complained about in Texas Death - it just never stopped, so you were never wasting time waiting around for someone to set up furniture, because there were more than enough people out there to do it while something else was going on.

I thought commentary had a shocker all night. Excalibur felt really off, and there was a point when he was about to throw to something backstage that he sounded genuinely choked up and I thought it was about to be a PAC tribute segment, so I don't know if just the weight of it all got to him or if there was something else going on with him, but it was an off night like I've not heard from him in a long time. Nigel had a horrendous moment in Mercedes vs. Marina, saying that it looked like Mercedes might be trying for a Brutalizer of her own, but instead just got "a simple crossface" - the "simple crossface" that is her finisher, Nigel!


The main event didn't really work for me. One of those matches where everything is perfectly polished and you know that everything they wanted to do went exactly to plan, but the plan just didn't do anything for me. It feels like we're past the crest of the wave of this kind of big epic match that's an awkward marriage of Omega-style escalation of big moves until it turns into a war of attrition and NXT-style melodrama and emoting, and maybe I've just seen too much of Ospreay in and out of the ring by now to just know exactly what he's trying to achieve every time one of those moments happens, and it just feels very forced. I'm glad they at least subverted the "wrestler passes out and inadvertently ducks out of the way of opponent's big strike" spot and "wrestler shouts their emotions and motivation at their opponent" spots by having Kyle Fletcher use both of them as traps laid for Ospreay, but the fact that those supposedly organic spots are now so rote that they can be subverted isn't a great sign.

No interest in MJF as Ospreay's next feud, either. Hated him interfering under a mask only to immediately remove it, because that's one of my wrestling pet hates as it is. Hated him dramatically revealing his title belt from his title belt bag as if it might have been anything else, on a show that already had at least two previous "what's in the bag?" spots. Hate the "real world champion" schtick anyway, not just because I don't feel like they've done the work to make it work, but because AEW has spent way too much of its time fucking with the World Title - they had CM Punk doing the Real World Champion angle, they had Jay White carrying the belt around after stealing it from MJF, they had Jon Moxley hiding the belt in a briefcase for a year, and now they've got MJF carrying his own version of the belt around with you; that's far too many ways to mess with the fact that the guy carrying the World Title should be demonstrably the most important part of the show. 

I haven't missed having MJF on TV, and don't think Dynamite will be improved by "we'll hear from MJF" every week. He and Ospreay bring out the worst in each other's promos, and one way that they do that is they both always try and tell ten stories when one would do, so they've already burned through most of their material the first time around. But I'm sure MJF saying something misogynistic about Alex Windsor, doing a shit British accent, and hitting three different catchphrase lines will be just as compelling this time.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...