Jump to content

PowerButchi

Moderators
  • Posts

    16,060
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by PowerButchi

  1. Graeme Hick should be the No.3 for England.

     

    They really fucked Hick's career by constantly carting him up and down the order and dropping him. If they'd have left him alone at number 3 and not arsed around with him he would have scored over 10,000 runs for England, no doubt about it.

    In an alternative universe where all of the world's fast bowlers were wiped out by a mystery virus, all of the world's test pitches were drained of their pace and life and England gave every opponent a 6-0 headstart to every series so that every match was a dead rubber, then yes Hick along with Rob Key and Owais Shah would be the all-time leading run-scorers.

     

    That's harsh. I don't think anyone with even a tiny amount of knowledge of the game could deny he was a fantasically gifted player. Indeed, no less an authority as Peter Roebuck said

     

    Hick's fate to be given an ability that did not suit his temperament

     

    which I think is far more fair. Being 6'4" never helped him against the short ball either. It's worth noting as well that he wasn't just in the England set up for his batting. He was known as an fine 2nd Slip (a level behind Jonty Rhodes in the field but who wasnt?) and an under used bowler of Off-breaks which is why he was so handy to take to the subcontinent. Half the reason he could never really play the short ball well is because he'd be dropped after a single poor score. With his well known mental fragility it knocked his confidence terribly, and also didn't really give him the chance to improve against World Class seamers and take his 1st Class form into the Test Arena. The way Ray Illingworth treated him was pretty shitty as well. When players like Shane Warne, Steve Waugh, Allan Donald and Beefy sing your praises from the rooftops you're not shit. Alex Stewart swore by him as well during his captaincy.

     

    He was a quality ODI player as well.

     

     

    I'd say Ramps suffered from England's 1990's "We want Results now!" ethos as well.

  2. Geoffrey Boycott has changed his opinion of Ponting today. Yesterday he was average and didn't have a cricketing brain, today he's one of the world's best. I imagine Boycott wants him to lower his strike rate though, he's hitting the ball a bit much. Did anyone find that 435 in 4 sessions was a very Unenglish score? Should have been about 178-7 by that point.

×
×
  • Create New...