Pick Your Power Game Thread

[Mafia Scum Scum]

It would help if Snake was here to post some sort of response to accusations made against him

 

I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft.

 

I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together.

[Ron Simmons]

It would help if Snake was here to post some sort of response to accusations made against him

 

I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft.

 

I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together.

Shouldn't trust anyone in this game, SMS. I'm not convinced by Snake at all. I've already acknowledged this, but it may very well be paranoia that's creating my doubts. I'm not sure if I'd feel this way had he not asked me to neighbour him, but since he has I'm suspicious of his motivations.

[Mafia Scum Scum]

It would help if Snake was here to post some sort of response to accusations made against him

 

I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft.

 

I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together.

Shouldn't trust anyone in this game, SMS. I'm not convinced by Snake at all. I've already acknowledged this, but it may very well be paranoia that's creating my doubts. I'm not sure if I'd feel this way had he not asked me to neighbour him, but since he has I'm suspicious of his motivations.

 

I might change my mind about who I trust, but every game I have played I have always found one or two players who I trust, sometimes I changed my mind and helped lynch them.

 

Just because I say I trust someone doesn't mean I am right and that I can't change my mind at any time.

[Retro Red]

So in order to avoid a no-lynch, the two of you move off of one of the 2 main wagons to try and start a third. With a day to deadline. You try to start a third wagon. To avoid a no-lynch. Amazing.

I think that's a tad unfair. Each person has three votes a piece, and we've over a day left to settle on a lynch. I've felt strongly about Lion since day one, and he's not done anything to change that today - he's just made me feel more and more wary of him. I'm also unsure about who I'd prefer to vote for out of swift and Snake. My gut's telling me Snake at this stage (Lion's made me second guess my swiftstrike vote pretty significantly), but I think it's heavily influenced by paranoia - scrap that - I KNOW it's heavily influenced by paranoia since I neighboured him.

 

Right now we have 4 people with votes. I want to see Snake lynched, I think he's the top suspect following this day's play and a secondary look at his and Nicko's play day one. SMS is next, simply just some alarmingly scummy posts from him today. Swift I'm not sure about, and I certainly don't think we should be lynching a VT claim simply because he's used potentially bad town play in volunteering to be lynched. Again this is like the ATG lynch yesterday. It's the easy option rather than taking a risk on an actual suspect. Everyone on the Lion wagon has plausible deniability tomorrow if he flips town, just like everyone on the ATG wagon did. It gives us no real information to help drive the third (and what should be) and decisive day.

What you're saying about Lion is exactly why I think he's scum. Why push a lynch on yourself - even when you've NO votes - if you're not scum? It doesn't make any sense to me. I was giving him the benefit of the doubt going into the day and thought swift needed to go. But his play has really set alarm bells ringing in my head. It IS the easy option - because it's the obvious option - and because of that I think it HAS to be the right option.

 

What's your opinion of Lion, Bristep? What kind of read to you get from him?

 

Snake is on 4 votes Ron, and has been since before the last time you said he had 3 votes.

 

Tell me this. If Lion gets lynched and flips town, what do we gain? Another town player gone, potentially 2 more overnight if there is an even night vig out there. that could leave us with 7 town and 4 scum and we are then potentially on our LAST DAY. No good information will be gained from lynching Lion, as if he is town then the whole wagon can sit and say "He asked to be lynched, bad town play, not my fault, blah" and tomorrow gets lost in the same mire that we're in today.

 

I say we get our fingers out of our arses and actually start driving the game. Lion is NOT a good lynch candidate today. Snake or Swift are, because there has been significant casework done on both, cohesive arguments around both, and a wagon we can actually pick apart tomorrow if we're wrong.

 

SMS and Snake are scum together, I'm now almost convinced of it. These lines from recent SMS posts just read super scumtacular

 

"I have been repeatedly saying I don't trust Lion, but I couldn't just vote for him before as I felt I was the only one wanting to vote for him, so as soon as somebody else voted Lion I joined in hoping to get more players onboard."

 

"I am not going to be V/LA before deadline so I can switch my vote over if I need to."

 

"I just have a very strong feeling he (snake) is town, just like I have a similar feeling about Lion being scum, but I obviously could be wrong."

 

"I am going to stand my ground and refuse to lynch Snake."

 

"Vote: Lion of the Midlands; If he turns up scum, then that is fantastic, but if we wrongly get town then at least he was Vanilla as he keeps reminding us."

 

"I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft."

 

"I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together."

 

"I might change my mind about who I trust, but every game I have played I have always found one or two players who I trust, sometimes I changed my mind and helped lynch them."

 

"Just because I say I trust someone doesn't mean I am right and that I can't change my mind at any time."

[Mafia Scum Scum]

So in order to avoid a no-lynch, the two of you move off of one of the 2 main wagons to try and start a third. With a day to deadline. You try to start a third wagon. To avoid a no-lynch. Amazing.

I think that's a tad unfair. Each person has three votes a piece, and we've over a day left to settle on a lynch. I've felt strongly about Lion since day one, and he's not done anything to change that today - he's just made me feel more and more wary of him. I'm also unsure about who I'd prefer to vote for out of swift and Snake. My gut's telling me Snake at this stage (Lion's made me second guess my swiftstrike vote pretty significantly), but I think it's heavily influenced by paranoia - scrap that - I KNOW it's heavily influenced by paranoia since I neighboured him.

 

Right now we have 4 people with votes. I want to see Snake lynched, I think he's the top suspect following this day's play and a secondary look at his and Nicko's play day one. SMS is next, simply just some alarmingly scummy posts from him today. Swift I'm not sure about, and I certainly don't think we should be lynching a VT claim simply because he's used potentially bad town play in volunteering to be lynched. Again this is like the ATG lynch yesterday. It's the easy option rather than taking a risk on an actual suspect. Everyone on the Lion wagon has plausible deniability tomorrow if he flips town, just like everyone on the ATG wagon did. It gives us no real information to help drive the third (and what should be) and decisive day.

What you're saying about Lion is exactly why I think he's scum. Why push a lynch on yourself - even when you've NO votes - if you're not scum? It doesn't make any sense to me. I was giving him the benefit of the doubt going into the day and thought swift needed to go. But his play has really set alarm bells ringing in my head. It IS the easy option - because it's the obvious option - and because of that I think it HAS to be the right option.

 

What's your opinion of Lion, Bristep? What kind of read to you get from him?

 

Snake is on 4 votes Ron, and has been since before the last time you said he had 3 votes.

 

Tell me this. If Lion gets lynched and flips town, what do we gain? Another town player gone, potentially 2 more overnight if there is an even night vig out there. that could leave us with 7 town and 4 scum and we are then potentially on our LAST DAY. No good information will be gained from lynching Lion, as if he is town then the whole wagon can sit and say "He asked to be lynched, bad town play, not my fault, blah" and tomorrow gets lost in the same mire that we're in today.

 

I say we get our fingers out of our arses and actually start driving the game. Lion is NOT a good lynch candidate today. Snake or Swift are, because there has been significant casework done on both, cohesive arguments around both, and a wagon we can actually pick apart tomorrow if we're wrong.

 

SMS and Snake are scum together, I'm now almost convinced of it. These lines from recent SMS posts just read super scumtacular

 

"I have been repeatedly saying I don't trust Lion, but I couldn't just vote for him before as I felt I was the only one wanting to vote for him, so as soon as somebody else voted Lion I joined in hoping to get more players onboard."

 

"I am not going to be V/LA before deadline so I can switch my vote over if I need to."

 

"I just have a very strong feeling he (snake) is town, just like I have a similar feeling about Lion being scum, but I obviously could be wrong."

 

"I am going to stand my ground and refuse to lynch Snake."

 

"Vote: Lion of the Midlands; If he turns up scum, then that is fantastic, but if we wrongly get town then at least he was Vanilla as he keeps reminding us."

 

"I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft."

 

"I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together."

 

"I might change my mind about who I trust, but every game I have played I have always found one or two players who I trust, sometimes I changed my mind and helped lynch them."

 

"Just because I say I trust someone doesn't mean I am right and that I can't change my mind at any time."

 

Well if you want, I could tell you why I believe he is town, but that would give the scum more of an advantage than it would town.

[Ron Simmons]

So in order to avoid a no-lynch, the two of you move off of one of the 2 main wagons to try and start a third. With a day to deadline. You try to start a third wagon. To avoid a no-lynch. Amazing.

I think that's a tad unfair. Each person has three votes a piece, and we've over a day left to settle on a lynch. I've felt strongly about Lion since day one, and he's not done anything to change that today - he's just made me feel more and more wary of him. I'm also unsure about who I'd prefer to vote for out of swift and Snake. My gut's telling me Snake at this stage (Lion's made me second guess my swiftstrike vote pretty significantly), but I think it's heavily influenced by paranoia - scrap that - I KNOW it's heavily influenced by paranoia since I neighboured him.

 

Right now we have 4 people with votes. I want to see Snake lynched, I think he's the top suspect following this day's play and a secondary look at his and Nicko's play day one. SMS is next, simply just some alarmingly scummy posts from him today. Swift I'm not sure about, and I certainly don't think we should be lynching a VT claim simply because he's used potentially bad town play in volunteering to be lynched. Again this is like the ATG lynch yesterday. It's the easy option rather than taking a risk on an actual suspect. Everyone on the Lion wagon has plausible deniability tomorrow if he flips town, just like everyone on the ATG wagon did. It gives us no real information to help drive the third (and what should be) and decisive day.

What you're saying about Lion is exactly why I think he's scum. Why push a lynch on yourself - even when you've NO votes - if you're not scum? It doesn't make any sense to me. I was giving him the benefit of the doubt going into the day and thought swift needed to go. But his play has really set alarm bells ringing in my head. It IS the easy option - because it's the obvious option - and because of that I think it HAS to be the right option.

 

What's your opinion of Lion, Bristep? What kind of read to you get from him?

 

Snake is on 4 votes Ron, and has been since before the last time you said he had 3 votes.

 

Tell me this. If Lion gets lynched and flips town, what do we gain? Another town player gone, potentially 2 more overnight if there is an even night vig out there. that could leave us with 7 town and 4 scum and we are then potentially on our LAST DAY. No good information will be gained from lynching Lion, as if he is town then the whole wagon can sit and say "He asked to be lynched, bad town play, not my fault, blah" and tomorrow gets lost in the same mire that we're in today.

 

I say we get our fingers out of our arses and actually start driving the game. Lion is NOT a good lynch candidate today. Snake or Swift are, because there has been significant casework done on both, cohesive arguments around both, and a wagon we can actually pick apart tomorrow if we're wrong.

 

SMS and Snake are scum together, I'm now almost convinced of it. These lines from recent SMS posts just read super scumtacular

 

"I have been repeatedly saying I don't trust Lion, but I couldn't just vote for him before as I felt I was the only one wanting to vote for him, so as soon as somebody else voted Lion I joined in hoping to get more players onboard."

 

"I am not going to be V/LA before deadline so I can switch my vote over if I need to."

 

"I just have a very strong feeling he (snake) is town, just like I have a similar feeling about Lion being scum, but I obviously could be wrong."

 

"I am going to stand my ground and refuse to lynch Snake."

 

"Vote: Lion of the Midlands; If he turns up scum, then that is fantastic, but if we wrongly get town then at least he was Vanilla as he keeps reminding us."

 

"I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft."

 

"I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together."

 

"I might change my mind about who I trust, but every game I have played I have always found one or two players who I trust, sometimes I changed my mind and helped lynch them."

 

"Just because I say I trust someone doesn't mean I am right and that I can't change my mind at any time."

Right, I've harped on about people being led by other players. I don't think SMS and Snake are together, I don't believe SMS would make it so blatant. BUT I do doubt Snake. I'll go with you on this one, but I'm as close to 100% as I can be that Lion is also scum. He's really scraping by here, and he should CERTAINLY be one of the top suspects tomorrow, if not THE top suspect. I URGE you all to re-read his posts and surely you'll see what I see.

 

I'm not completely happy about this because I know there's an element of paranoia in my suspicions. But:

unvote

 

Vote Snake Plissken

[Ron Simmons]

So in order to avoid a no-lynch, the two of you move off of one of the 2 main wagons to try and start a third. With a day to deadline. You try to start a third wagon. To avoid a no-lynch. Amazing.

I think that's a tad unfair. Each person has three votes a piece, and we've over a day left to settle on a lynch. I've felt strongly about Lion since day one, and he's not done anything to change that today - he's just made me feel more and more wary of him. I'm also unsure about who I'd prefer to vote for out of swift and Snake. My gut's telling me Snake at this stage (Lion's made me second guess my swiftstrike vote pretty significantly), but I think it's heavily influenced by paranoia - scrap that - I KNOW it's heavily influenced by paranoia since I neighboured him.

 

Right now we have 4 people with votes. I want to see Snake lynched, I think he's the top suspect following this day's play and a secondary look at his and Nicko's play day one. SMS is next, simply just some alarmingly scummy posts from him today. Swift I'm not sure about, and I certainly don't think we should be lynching a VT claim simply because he's used potentially bad town play in volunteering to be lynched. Again this is like the ATG lynch yesterday. It's the easy option rather than taking a risk on an actual suspect. Everyone on the Lion wagon has plausible deniability tomorrow if he flips town, just like everyone on the ATG wagon did. It gives us no real information to help drive the third (and what should be) and decisive day.

What you're saying about Lion is exactly why I think he's scum. Why push a lynch on yourself - even when you've NO votes - if you're not scum? It doesn't make any sense to me. I was giving him the benefit of the doubt going into the day and thought swift needed to go. But his play has really set alarm bells ringing in my head. It IS the easy option - because it's the obvious option - and because of that I think it HAS to be the right option.

 

What's your opinion of Lion, Bristep? What kind of read to you get from him?

 

Snake is on 4 votes Ron, and has been since before the last time you said he had 3 votes.

 

Tell me this. If Lion gets lynched and flips town, what do we gain? Another town player gone, potentially 2 more overnight if there is an even night vig out there. that could leave us with 7 town and 4 scum and we are then potentially on our LAST DAY. No good information will be gained from lynching Lion, as if he is town then the whole wagon can sit and say "He asked to be lynched, bad town play, not my fault, blah" and tomorrow gets lost in the same mire that we're in today.

 

I say we get our fingers out of our arses and actually start driving the game. Lion is NOT a good lynch candidate today. Snake or Swift are, because there has been significant casework done on both, cohesive arguments around both, and a wagon we can actually pick apart tomorrow if we're wrong.

 

SMS and Snake are scum together, I'm now almost convinced of it. These lines from recent SMS posts just read super scumtacular

 

"I have been repeatedly saying I don't trust Lion, but I couldn't just vote for him before as I felt I was the only one wanting to vote for him, so as soon as somebody else voted Lion I joined in hoping to get more players onboard."

 

"I am not going to be V/LA before deadline so I can switch my vote over if I need to."

 

"I just have a very strong feeling he (snake) is town, just like I have a similar feeling about Lion being scum, but I obviously could be wrong."

 

"I am going to stand my ground and refuse to lynch Snake."

 

"Vote: Lion of the Midlands; If he turns up scum, then that is fantastic, but if we wrongly get town then at least he was Vanilla as he keeps reminding us."

 

"I trust Snake, am pretty sure he will have something good to tell you, as he was high up on the draft."

 

"I also think you are town also Ron, so I hope you two are able to share any info you have, as well as try and come up with kind of strategy to work together."

 

"I might change my mind about who I trust, but every game I have played I have always found one or two players who I trust, sometimes I changed my mind and helped lynch them."

 

"Just because I say I trust someone doesn't mean I am right and that I can't change my mind at any time."

 

Well if you want, I could tell you why I believe he is town, but that would give the scum more of an advantage than it would town.

How? The scum already know whether he's town or not. Witholding info led to your incorrect lynch last game, so please don't try that again. I DO think you're town, but I also think if you repeat your mistakes from the last game other people won't be so keen to give you the benefit of the doubt - OR the scum will nail you.

[Mafia Scum Scum]

I know what role he has, but if I tell you what or how I know, it would mean revealing too much info.

[Ron Simmons]

I know what role he has, but if I tell you what or how I know, it would mean revealing too much info.

Well you're essentially role-claiming here, that's the only way you could know what role he has. That statement actually doesn't sit all that well with me, and I'm beginning to feel a little more comfortable with my vote for Snake.

 

FOS SMS

[Ron Simmons]

EBWOP: Looking at the roles that are left aside from mine, I don't think there are ANY which would automatically confirm a player as town, they'd all have their use to the scum in some way or other.

[Mafia Scum Scum]

EBWOP: Looking at the roles that are left aside from mine, I don't think there are ANY which would automatically confirm a player as town, they'd all have their use to the scum in some way or other.

 

Wrong!

 

A cop would so long as we don't have a framer in the game.

 

I am going to have to roleclaim soon, as we don't have much time left to organise a vote, and I won't stand by and watch Snake get lynched.

[Nexus]

FGS SMS

 

If you have information that will prevent a townie mislynch, then come forward and say it

 

Stop with the cryptic messages. That's anti-town.

 

vote: SMS

 

It's not leaving until you tell us your information.(Bear in mind the last time you claimed to have information in a game, you got lynched and it turned out to be bullshit anyway)

[Mafia Scum Scum]

FGS SMS

 

If you have information that will prevent a townie mislynch, then come forward and say it

 

Stop with the cryptic messages. That's anti-town.

 

vote: SMS

 

It's not leaving until you tell us your information.(Bear in mind the last time you claimed to have information in a game, you got lynched and it turned out to be bullshit anyway)

 

Very well, but you folk asked for it, so don't blame me for revealing it.

 

I chose the rolecop role, so know Snakes role as I investigated him last night, so that is how I know.

 

Why did I chose a scum role?

 

I felt it was a role they would probably go for, so they would lose one power role and end up with a goon, plus it might come in useful alongside the cop role as if I discovered the framer or another scum role I could bring it to other peoples attention.

 

Don't believe me then lynch me, then see me flip town, but I won't reveal Snakes role till I am close to lynch or if he wants to himself.

[Ron Simmons]

EBWOP: Looking at the roles that are left aside from mine, I don't think there are ANY which would automatically confirm a player as town, they'd all have their use to the scum in some way or other.

 

Wrong!

 

A cop would so long as we don't have a framer in the game.

 

I am going to have to roleclaim soon, as we don't have much time left to organise a vote, and I won't stand by and watch Snake get lynched.

Actually if the scum managed to nab the cop role that would prevent it from getting into the hands of the town, meaning it's incredibly useful to them.

 

Why did I chose a scum role?

Who said Rolecop was a scum role? Sure it's useful to them, but it's also useful to the town in terms of working out who has the vigilante roles (for example, if town players continually die we know that said role has possibly gotten into the hands of scum.)

[Ron Simmons]

EBWOP:

 

unvote

 

If Snake IS a cop, and he IS town voting him would be stupid. I don't know if I buy all of this, but I don't want to take any risks either.